New Report: USMCA “Digital Trade” Rules Threaten AI Oversight and Kids’ Online Safety Laws

Will Democrats Insist Trump Strip Big Tech Secrecy Protections from the Deal During 2027 Renegotiations?

November 20, 2026

Press Contact: Allie Gross, agross@economicliberties.us

New Report: USMCA “Digital Trade” Rules Threaten AI Oversight and Kids’ Online Safety Laws 

Will Democrats Insist Trump Strip Big Tech Secrecy Protections from the Deal During 2027 Renegotiations?

Washington, D.C. –  After an election in which AI data centers, kids online safety, and Big Tech power played a major role for voters, a new report from the American Economic Liberties Project’s Rethink Trade program reveals how Big Tech secrecy guarantees in the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA) undermine the oversight tools at the heart of recently-passed state AI and kids’ online safety laws and congressional proposals. The report also details how the USMCA renegotiation, expected to intensify in 2027, could fix the problem.

“The Trump administration says only U.S. policymakers should decide U.S. digital regulation. So will they eliminate the USMCA terms that internationally preempt U.S. state laws and Congress’ authority to decide what AI policy is in the U.S. national interest?” said Lori Wallach, Director of the Rethink Trade program at American Economic Liberties Project.   

“If we want effective oversight of AI systems, we cannot let trade rules become a barrier to the safeguards policymakers are working to put in place, which makes USMCA renegotiations a unique opportunity to fix this,” said Luis Fernando Chavez, Rethink Trade Policy Analyst and the report’s lead author. 

The problem is USMCA Article 19.16. This “digital trade” rule bars governments from requiring access to source code, algorithms, and other information that independent auditors need to inspect AI systems and social media platforms. This is a secrecy guarantee for digital corporations that go beyond the standard “trade secrets” rules for confidential business information. Nearly every major AI safety and kids’ online safety law relies on exactly that kind of information being accessible to conduct independent audits. 

The report provides side-by-side analysis showing where specific laws and bills collide with the USMCA rules. 

At the federal level: the bipartisan Kids Online Safety Act, the FRONTIER Act (H.R. 9925), and the AI Risk Evaluation Act (S. 2938) all require independent audits or evaluations that could necessitate access to source code, algorithms, or model weights covered by the USMCA rule. 

At the state level: Illinois’ Artificial Intelligence Safety Measures Act, California’s Adam’s Law on companion chatbots, and Texas’ SCOPE Act all depend on auditor access to information USMCA restricts. 

The rules do damage even without a formal trade dispute. Companies could raise USMCA objections — or lobby their governments to do so —  and the mere prospect of a challenge chills regulation. A similar source code secrecy rule in the EU-UK trade agreement led the EU to narrow its AI oversight policies, a Mexican AI proposal was watered down after industry claimed it conflicted with USMCA “digital trade” terms, and the Trump administration is currently wielding the same rules against Canadian digital policies.

The three USMCA countries are now engaged in the pact’s mandatory six-year review, a rare opportunity to strip these provisions out before they become the global standard. 

Rethink Trade’s previous report, International Preemption by “Trade” Agreement, provides further analysis on conflicts between bipartisan U.S. legislation and “digital trade” rules.

Read the full memo here. 

Rethink Trade is a program of the American Economic Liberties Project. 

Learn more about Economic Liberties and Rethink Trade.


The American Economic Liberties Project works to ensure America’s system of commerce is structured to advance, rather than undermine, economic liberty, fair commerce, and a secure, inclusive democracy. Economic Liberties believes true economic liberty means entrepreneurs and businesses large and small succeed on the merits of their ideas and hard work; commerce empowers consumers, workers, farmers, and engineers instead of subjecting them to discrimination and abuse from financiers and monopolists; foreign trade arrangements support domestic productive capacity, resilience and democracy; and wealth is broadly distributed to support equitable political power.